The Creator is a science fiction action film produced and directed by Gareth Edwards. The film treats the complex relationship between AI — here represented as ‘human simulators’ — and the human species.
It’s 2070, Los Angeles that has been nuked by AI 15 years prior. Following that event, the Western world tried to ban AI, while a not-so-imaginary place on earth called ‘New Asia’ is still accepting and embracing simulators as part of their society.
In an attempt to protect human beings from going extinct, and to reach his lost pregnant wife, Maya, U.S. Army sergeant Joshua Taylor, played by a forgettable John David Washington, kidnaps the ultimate AI weapon, a little simulator girl played by a magnetic and intense Madeleine Yuna Voyles.
The film becomes almost two different films developing side by side: on one hand, we have the relationship between Joshua and the little AI girl — nicknamed Alfie — and on the other hand, we have the war between AI and humans.
Unfortunately, due in part to the lack of stage presence of Washington, and in part to the script, the relationship between Joshua and Alfie fails to deliver the power, the intimacy, and the urgency to the audience. The story never really reaches deep levels of humanity and ends up feeling a bit superficial.
Another jarring note is the use of ‘generic Asian people’ to represent all the AI simulators. I don’t exactly understand what is the director trying to aim at, if it’s to give a visual contrast between the Western world and the AI, or if it’s just a way to add Asian themes such as Hinduism and Buddhism to the mix. Maybe Edwards, who wrote the script with Chris Weitz, was trying to give more depth to a plot that lacked substance and biting.
The pacing of the movie seemed to be a bit off too, with the camera dwelling in some scenes, while some other moments felt rushed to the point they made the plot slightly incomprehensible.
That said, the visual effects are glorious, the cinematography is magnificent and the overall aesthetic is very well done. Surprisingly, a film that relies profoundly on visuals was shot with an entry-level full-frame mirrorless camera designed for beginners such as the Sony FX3, a bold choice for a film that comes out also on IMAX.
Unfortunately, the overall film leaves a sense of emptiness. With an 80 million dollar budget, I feel like Edwards missed a good chance to explore the future of AI — at least, a sci-fi version of it — on a deep level, with an actual consequence on the human side of relationships.
A beautiful film that doesn’t aim at the soul.
