GLOBAL CINEMA · INDEPENDENT VOICESTHE ART OF FILM / STORIES THAT MATTER

She Came to Me

Original film or screenplay review from the Cinemawide archive.

She Came to Me

She Came To Me, the new dramedy by Rebecca Miller came out quite stealthily among a series of blockbusters such as The Creator, Saw X, and the highly anticipated Taylor Swift: The Eras Tour — despite featuring stars such as Peter Dinklage, Marisa Tomei, and Anne Hathaway.

Steven is an Opera composer fighting writer’s block. His wife Patricia — who was his former therapist and is played by Anne Hathaway — is a cold, anal-retentive, hyper-zealous psychologist, wife, and mother. Her son, born from a previous relationship, lives with her and Steven full-time.

One day, after being encouraged to get out of his luxurious NY brownstone to take his dog for a walk, Steven finds himself seduced by tugboat captain Katrina, played by an excellent Marisa Tomei and ends up getting dragged into her boat and having sex with her.

Full of remorse, but finally inspired, Steven goes back home to write what would be his best Opera yet.

The film plays around the fact that everybody in NY has an interesting story to tell, and by just going out one day you could get dragged into the most absurd situation possible. Having lived in NY for about nine years, these stories seem honestly to be quite plausible too!

While Steven’s storyline unfolds, Patricia’s son Julian falls in love with his school friend Tereza, who, unbeknownst to all the parties involved, is the daughter of Patricia and Steven’s undocumented housekeeper Magdalena from her previous relationship, who is now married to Tereza’s stepfather. The two plots will develop at the same time and will guarantee a double happy ending to the intricate story.

The script is extraordinarily well written. All of the absurd elements of the film blend together quite nicely, as they find rest in knowing that the superb performances and chemistry between Dinklage and Tomei would match their quirkiness (and more), creating a picture that’s suspended between being at the same time hyper-realistic and surreal, down-to-earth and ethereal.

Miller’s choice to change the picture ratio every now and then is quite interesting. The format would go from 16:9 to 4:3 whenever Steven would go to the tugboat. Most of the time, the ration wouldn’t be noticeable right away, but it would definitely add to the overall visual sensation left to the audience: whenever we’re in the tugboat, the image feels restricted and claustrophobic, whenever we’re in Steven’s NY brownstone, everything feels airy and fresh.

One last positive note is the rich and opulent set design, starting from the opera house to the aseptic brownstone, to the eclectic tugboat. Every part of the frame is filled with visual elements, which accompany the actors and their performances quite beautifully.

A film that’s neither this nor that, you can absolutely love it (like I did) or you could hate it, but it’s undoubtedly a good time spent walking by the streets of NYC in the company of funny and eccentric people. Great work!

← Browse all reviews