GLOBAL CINEMA · INDEPENDENT VOICESTHE ART OF FILM / STORIES THAT MATTER

Oppenheimer

Original film or screenplay review from the Cinemawide archive.

Oppenheimer

Oppenheimer is a film about the rise of J. Robert Oppenheimer in his studies on atomic energy, from the beginning of his career to the end of his life.

At the very beginning of the film, one professor asks a young J. Robert Oppenheimer: A musician is not one who can read sheet music, but one who can hear the music  (I’m paraphrasing). And sound is in fact a key element in Christopher Nolan’s new film. At times completely absent, at times going on and off — just like a ticking bomb — the sound very much mirrors Oppenheimer’s feelings throughout the 3-hour movie.

The film is very well directed — of course, it’s Nolan — and it’s very well produced too. I’m always a bit uncomfortable when I see aging makeup on screen, most times you can definitely tell where the prosthetics are on the face, but in this film, the aging was done absolutely beautifully — no big noses or lumpy cracked lips — which definitely helped understand the time jumps of each scene. Not an easy task for a film that tirelessly goes back and forth from the twenties to the sixties, to the fifties, and back to the forties.

The plot of the film is nothing we haven’t seen before. It traces the creation of the atomic bomb during the Manhattan Project, from the point of view of its inventor, J. Robert Oppenheimer. But Nolan does so in non-linear storytelling that allows him to show the main character’s private and professional life and investigate his doubts and fears.

Whenever I look at period films with male characters at their center, I can never help but wonder how the director and casting department choose which actor gets which role. With more than twenty of them being 30-40-something-white-good-looking-smart men, most of the characters and actors seem to be interchangeable to me. On the other hand, how difficult it must be to cast only two female roles in a deeply male-dominated film. Emily Blunt was absolutely fantastic in her role, and I honestly love all of her work. However, the role of Florence Pugh could have been performed by pretty much any other “good-looking” actress (I’m looking at this from a male’s perspective), the role being very much of appearance and not much of substance.

In fact, I read recently that Nolan apologized several times to Pugh for the size of the role of Jean Tatlock he was offering her, and after I watched the movie I understood why. Mind you, most actors/actresses would give an arm to be on set with Nolan for even one second, but I don’t think he was referring to her actual screen time. I felt like her character was under-written and under-developed, and was generally lacking depth, especially being Jean Tatlock the “problematic” character who was going through psychiatric treatment.

Matt Damon’s portrayal of Leslie Groves would always get a laugh in the room. His performance was over-the-top and Damon managed to make him seem surprisingly cute and likeable for a General.

Now, let’s get to the real main character. Cillian Murphy’s piercing and penetrating blue eyes. I remember studying at some point in high school the difference between the “looking eye” and the “eye being looked at” as defined by Jean-Paul Sartre (referring to the conscience of the ego. Unfortunately, my memories of philosophy class start and end here), and throughout the film, Murphy’s eyes appear to be “looked at”. They are present and absent at the same time. He absorbs information without expressing any judgment or ego.

He simply exists.

And the depth and presence of his eyes were indeed the most magical element of the film.

That and the long awaited explosion of course — expertly and beautifully shot, only with visual and almost no sound.

The film leaves a few things unsolved, like why Oppenheimer desired to go through a 4-week long hearing knowing that the outcome was predetermined. Or why was Oppenheimer actually on board with the creation of the bomb, knowing that the Nazis had already backed out, only to have remorses right after the bomb was dropped.

A beautiful masterpiece that doesn't offer any original point of view but will likely glue you to your seat for 3 hours straight.

← Browse all reviews