GLOBAL CINEMA · INDEPENDENT VOICESTHE ART OF FILM / STORIES THAT MATTER

Killers of the Flower Moon

Original film or screenplay review from the Cinemawide archive.

Killers of the Flower Moon

Killers of the Flower Moon is Martin Scorsese’s latest epic crime movie about the massacres of the Osage Nation, adapted from the homonymous #1 New York Times bestseller by David Grann, and featuring two of Scorsese’s most frequent collaborators, Robert De Niro as Willian King Hale — a wealthy rancher also known as “King of the Osage Hills” who presents himself as a friend of the Osage — and Leonardo Di Caprio as William’s nephew Ernest Burkhart — a WWI veteran who moves in with his uncle after serving in the army as a cook.

It’s the 1920s, and the Osage are some of the wealthiest people in the entire country thanks to newfound oil in their Reservation. From that moment on starts a sort of “gold rush” among all the white men to marry all the Osage women in order to inherit their money. William Hale is eager to use his blue-eyed nephew Ernest as bait to get his hands on Mollie, a rich Osage woman, masterfully played by Lily Gladstone. Ernest, who now works as a cab driver, soon falls in love with Mollie and they start building their own family, under the content eyes of his uncle. Soon after the wedding, Mollie starts getting sick, and Mollie’s family will start to die, one by one, under mysterious circumstances, and with no investigation whatsoever.

From the very beginning, it’s obvious to the audience that William is the instigator of all the crimes and that Ernest, nolens volens, is his facilitator. Without the suspense created by not knowing who the bad guys are, it’s really hard to create a film that’s engaging and captivating, and for that reason, the entire film seems really slow to me. If we’re not glued to our chairs to find out who was the one plotting and scheming all these bloody murders, then why should we? As a matter of fact, this film was quite difficult to sit through especially being over 200 minutes long.

Another thing that didn’t sit quite right with me was the total lack of justification for the trust and reliance Osage people had for white men. Killers of the Flower Moon is recounting true events, which I get, but I would have liked to see more incertitude, more ambivalence, more torment in the Osage people in their decisions to trust William and Ernest and all the other white men with their families, their money and basically their lives. It really only took one scene for Mollie to be completely smitten with simple-minded cab driver Ernest. And two scenes for them to become engaged.

The film is way too long for me, a lot of scenes seem to drag a bit, especially the ones between Di Caprio and De Niro, which honestly left me with a desire for more ruthless editing… On the other hand, I wish Lily Gladstone — as well as her Native American co-stars — had way more screen time than what Scorsese granted them. Not only was she absolutely wonderful in her role, with the poise and aplomb in her face practically carrying the whole film, but this is, in the end, a film about Native Americans! On top of that, I found her dynamics with her sisters to be way more interesting than the relationship between the two murderous white men.

It’s worth saying that Scorsese is still Scorsese, his directing is extremely well done, the cinematography is glorious and the production design and costumes are absolutely impeccable. But the film looks like a Western version of a mafia movie, a format that has been seen in every possible way.

A gorgeous and skillful stylistic exercise about an extremely interesting and unexplored topic.

← Browse all reviews