Dicks: The Musical is a new film directed by legendary Larry Charles — famous for directing the Borat movies among others — and based on the off-Broadway musical Fucking Identical Twins by Josh Sharp and Aaron Jackson. The film stars Sharp and Jackson as two (not-so-identical) twins who re-enact a queer and musical version of Disney’s success The Parent Trap.
Two extremely straight CIS salesmen realize by working together that they are identical twins and were separated at birth. One ended up living with their dad, played by Nathan Lane, and one ended up living with their mom, played by Megan Mullally.
The parents are an ultra-eccentric version of old New Yorkers who have seen and done it all. The mom had her vagina fall off and chased her like a spider in Greece, while the gay dad lives with two “sewer boys”, two creatures he found in the NY sewer system that he adopted decades ago and keeps in cages.
The two twins then make a plan to have their parents fall in love with each other so that they can all be a family again, but of course, things don't go their way.
Trying too hard to be edgy, weird, and outrageous, the film lacks essence, a meaningful plot, and well-developed characters. Sharp and Jackson’s characters are one-dimensional, they deliver puns one after the other but lack complete depth, personality layers, and really just basic humanity... The writers and the director try so hard to make their characters seem like a parody but fail to remember that parody needs to lie on some substance, otherwise, it’s just useless mimics.
DICKS: THE MUSICAL seems forced, and the two main actors aren't able to pull off their performances. They are not conveying at all the distress they are parodying, which would be essential in this case. There is a special type of presence and charisma an actor needs to sing songs about balls, cum, and vaginas, and Sharp and Jackson just don’t have it.
The only good performance is Nathan Lane’s one. He is the only one in my opinion capable of keeping his character grounded amidst all the shenanigans happening around him.
I am not exactly a fan of casting Megan Mullally as the twins’ mom. Although she has been great in many roles in her career, I feel like the writing and the direction restricted her to a wheelchair-bound-lisping grandma, and that did not serve her performance at all.
The songs though were the least memorable thing of the movie, and for a musical, the bare minimum would be to have songs that are somewhat catchy and fun to listen to.
The end result is not as smart or as funny as it think it is. The gags fluctuate in a limbo of offensive jokes, but without two actors really *being* offensive. Sharp and Jackson indicate that they are two cis straight men, but they *are* not it, they are not truly living their characters' lives.
Comparing this musical to another quirky comedy out in theatres now, Bottoms, the difference between the two is crystal clear. In Bottoms, the two actresses completely and fully embody the characters, they deliver performances that are real, even when everything around them is as absurd and offensive.
Here, Sharp and Jackson’s performances are superficial, SNL-like sketches that can be tolerated for a few minutes tops, let alone for a whole hour and a half, and let alone in a musical act!
The finale with the two twins realizing they are in love with each other and getting married — in front of a gay God — is the cherry on top of a cake we didn’t want to eat in the first place.
Funny concept, but really awkward and uncertain realization. Unfortunately, this film will soon be forgotten.
