A joke in This Is Spinal Tap can depend on a musician taking a silly question very seriously. Rob Reiner understood how much funnier the answer becomes when the person giving it believes he is clearing something up. The concert footage and interviews feel convincing enough to catch the comedy as it goes by. Reiner appears as the documentarian, which gives him a particularly useful spot from which to let the band talk.
Reiner died in December 2025 at 78. Before directing, he was widely known as Mike Stivic on All in the Family. The range of his films can sound like a list of unrelated assignments. Put Stand by Me beside The Princess Bride and you can hear how much both films care about who is telling a story, and who is old enough to recognize the storyteller’s little evasions.
He gives Harry and Sally something similar to do in Nora Ephron’s When Harry Met Sally…. Their arguments offer them a way to spend time together without having to agree on what that time means. Reiner can afford to hold on a reaction because the performers have already made the characters’ attention to each other interesting.
Misery shows how far that trust in conversation can go. A writer and his most devoted reader are stuck in a room where any apparently courteous request can acquire a second meaning. Reiner had a feel for the moment an audience understands something just before one of the people on screen. It can produce laughter or dread. He knew how long to give us to enjoy being ahead.
