In Training Day, Alonzo Harris spends much of the working day telling a younger officer how the city operates. Denzel Washington makes him an engaging teacher, which is essential to understanding the danger of the lesson. He can answer an objection with a story and leave his pupil working out whether a conversation has just ended or a new instruction has been given. The force of the performance comes from how much other people want to believe that Alonzo knows the rules.
Malcolm X asks Washington to carry changes in conviction through changes in address. A man speaking to a crowd, explaining himself to someone close to him and trying to take the measure of his own earlier beliefs has different work to do in each case. The performance gives those situations their own rhythm. Spike Lee can show the power of public speech while preserving the person who has to make decisions once the speech is over.
In Fences, which Washington directed as well as starred in, Troy Maxson can hold the yard with a story. His family has heard the confidence before and knows the cost of living with it. Viola Davis has space to show what it takes for Rose to get a point across to someone used to determining when a conversation is finished. Washington’s decisions as a director make room for the challenge to his character’s account of himself.
He won Academy Awards for Glory and Training Day. Across the performances, the thing to watch is how quickly he can hear a change in someone’s willingness to listen. A scene can turn at that instant, with Washington letting the character decide whether to push harder or try a different way to be understood.
