An actor who can look like anyone should be Hollywood’s ideal employee. In Clayface, that ability comes after Matt Hagen discovers how quickly his industry will stop looking at him. Tom Rhys Harries plays a star who is disfigured by a gangster and turns to an experimental treatment. Back in front of a mirror, Hagen gets the face he wanted and loses any guarantee it will still be there a minute later. That is a much better origin for a horror film than a lesson in where a future Batman villain got his powers.
The physical effects make the premise specific. When Hagen’s eyelids fuse in an airplane bathroom, he has very little room to do anything about it and a cabin full of strangers on the other side of the door. The location turns a transformation into an actor’s problem. He has to find out what his face can still do and somehow get back to his seat looking like an ordinary passenger. It is a sharper use of the character’s predicament than any amount of dialogue about losing his identity.
Naomi Ackie’s Dr. Caitlyn Corr opens another line of inquiry. Her treatment is intended to help repair bodies. Hagen wants it to repair a career, a reputation and the story he tells about himself. Once the story settles on revenge, it has an obvious destination. The more unsettling prospect is that he could put his enemies behind him and still have no way to tell whether the life he wants back ever belonged entirely to him.
The originality is in what the story treats as a loss. Hagen becomes capable of manufacturing another face at will. In a city and an industry that trade in appearances, that makes him valuable again. It also makes the question of what he’s returning to almost unbearable. Clayface has more to say about that bargain than any Gotham mythology it could have spent the time explaining.



