In Home Alone, Catherine O’Hara has to sell a fear the audience can afford to laugh at. We know Kevin has the house under control, at least by Kevin’s standards. Kate McCallister has no such information. O’Hara keeps the distance between those two realities alive. Every setback on the way home is genuinely awful for Kate, which gives the film a pulse whenever it leaves the traps behind.
O’Hara died in January 2026 at 71. Her career took her from Toronto’s Second City and SCTV to Tim Burton’s Beetlejuice, Christopher Guest’s ensemble films and Schitt’s Creek. The same skill travels across those worlds. She can let a character make a spectacular social error while showing us the perfectly reasonable sequence of thoughts that produced it.
In Best in Show, that quality belongs to Cookie Fleck, one half of a married couple heading to a dog show. Cookie is comfortable enough in her own skin to make other people uncomfortable. O’Hara and Eugene Levy leave enough space between their reactions for a whole marriage to appear. It feels as though they have been hearing versions of these stories for years.
Moira Rose, the role that earned O’Hara an Emmy, took the voice and the wardrobe in a less ordinary direction. Still, the choices make sense for a former soap star who has lost the circumstances in which she knows how to be herself. Moira treats a conversation like an audition for a life she means to get back. O’Hara lets the effort show, then gives her one more improbable word to say.
