In Carol, a visit to a department store places Cate Blanchett on one side of a counter and Rooney Mara on the other. The encounter has a practical reason to continue for another moment. That gives Blanchett the opportunity to let interest travel under the ordinary courtesies of shopping. The film can take its time because there is already something at stake in how long one woman is willing to look at the other.
Jasmine, in Blue Jasmine, puts similar attention into holding a room for very different reasons. Formerly wealthy and living with her sister, she can turn a conversation into a recital of the life she thinks she should still have. Blanchett lets that practiced manner slip just enough to reveal how much work goes into keeping it going. The instability of the performance belongs to the character, even when Jasmine insists that everyone else is being unreasonable.
Tár puts the habits of command inside an institution. Lydia is an acclaimed conductor who can use a rehearsal or a conversation to set the terms on which other people may speak. Blanchett gives Lydia enough professional intelligence to make the arrangement credible. The pleasure of watching someone exercise a real skill makes it more important to notice what that person is doing with the authority the skill confers.
She won Oscars for The Aviator and Blue Jasmine. Put those roles beside Carol and Tár, and the part of her technique worth looking for is the adjustment she makes when a character understands that she is being watched. The performance can be quiet and still show the calculation taking place.
