Getting into a federal building is the beginning of Being Heumann. Staying in it is the story. In 1977, Judy Heumann and the other activists occupying a San Francisco federal office demanded that the government enforce Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act. Siân Heder organizes her film around a sustained action. A demand made on the first day looks different when people must keep themselves fed, connected and heard for weeks.
Ruth Madeley plays Heumann, with Madeline Delp as Kitty Cone. Both have a reason to be impatient, and the film makes good use of the fact that they can disagree while working on the same problem. In a protest that lasts this long, persistence can mean having the same argument again with an ally who has a different idea of what should happen next. The disabled ensemble makes the negotiations legible as the work of people who need one another and can still get on one another’s nerves.
A story named after one person has to decide how to represent a change made by many. The film gets more specific once it settles into the occupation. A scene has something to do when people must decide how to get a message outside or keep an alliance together. The more familiar scenes in which officials dismiss the protesters are clear enough about the obstacle. The daily decisions inside the building do more to explain why this particular action endured.
The film’s most rewarding subject is the occupation’s temporary community. By keeping people in one building long enough to show the effort it took to stay there, Being Heumann makes the achievement concrete. The thing worth celebrating was also very hard to organize.




